Peter Davenport
When You Were MinePeter Davenport, Isobel Davenport’s brother and Dominic Cavendish’s friend, moves through the story from presumed bereavement to the discovery that his sister is alive. His response to her disappearance is both personal and practical: he grieves beside her grave, seeks answers about how she was taken and buried, and later recognizes that her safety lies with Dominic. Peter’s reactions make him a witness to the damage Rupert Davenport has caused and an ally in the effort to protect Isobel.
Identity and Background
Peter is connected to Isobel through their family and to Dominic through friendship. His absence during the events at Willowbrook Hall is consequential: he has been in Norfolk helping capture smugglers, and those at the house believe he, too, has been killed by the lawless men. When he returns, his survival is a shock to his aunt Elspeth, whose distress has already been intensified by Isobel’s removal.
Peter comes back to a household in confusion. Rupert had invoked his guardianship to take Isobel from Elspeth’s care, using threats and insults to overcome her objections and threatening violence if she tried to prevent the removal. Elspeth last saw Isobel in a brief, tearful farewell before Rupert put her into an unmarked carriage and drove away. No word has reached the household since. Peter learns not only that his sister has disappeared, but that Rupert secured Elspeth’s compliance through intimidation and lies. The staff had also been told that Isobel was betrothed to Bertram DeLisle shortly before she vanished, a claim that adds to the uncertainty surrounding Rupert’s account of her fate.
Grief and the Search for Answers
Two months later, Peter is with Dominic in Leicestershire at the grave believed to be Isobel’s. A roughly made wooden cross marks the recently dug earth; weeds have already begun to cover it. Peter rhythmically pulls at the growth and twists the uprooted weeds around the cross. The quiet, repetitive task gives physical form to grief that neither man can resolve by looking at the grave. Dominic sits beside him in the rain, mourning Isobel as the woman he adored and had wanted to marry; Peter’s own loss is that of a brother who believes his sister has been taken from him permanently.
Peter does not let mourning end with the grave visit. He tells Dominic to continue with his life and not allow grief to make him bitter. His counsel is an attempt to keep his friend from being consumed by loss, but Dominic refuses consolation: he says his life remains with Isobel and insists that Rupert must answer for what he has done. Peter therefore witnesses a difference in how the two men bear the presumed death. He urges endurance; Dominic turns sorrow into a vow of vengeance.
Peter also seeks an official explanation and a more fitting resting place for Isobel. He has sent word to the Magistrate to meet them at the grave, because he wants answers about why she was buried so quickly. He objects to leaving her in a desolate place and wants her returned to Willowbrook Hall to be interred in the family crypt with their parents. His concern joins the intimate rituals of mourning to a demand for accountability: the makeshift cross and hurried burial are not, in his view, an acceptable conclusion to the matter.
Finding Isobel Alive
Peter’s understanding changes when he visits Dominic’s home. He knows Isobel has been significantly ill and insists on seeing her rather than accepting the butler’s evasiveness. Familiar with the house from earlier visits, he goes upstairs and opens the door to the master suite. There he finds Isobel alive, in bed beside Dominic. Peter presents an angry front, protesting that Dominic has compromised his sister, but his inward response is relief and happiness: she is alive, relatively well, and with the man he believes will marry her and protect her from Rupert.
The contrast between Peter’s public rebuke and private delight reveals his priorities. He recognizes the risk to Isobel’s reputation, yet he does not mistake propriety for the most urgent issue. After believing her dead, he is glad to find her safe with Dominic. His mock anger lets him acknowledge the social difficulty of her situation without withdrawing his approval of the protection and future Dominic can offer.
Family Loyalty and Isobel’s Safety
Peter also learns that Isobel’s escape involved a disguise. Dominic explains that they found her in men’s clothing, possibly Peter’s: thick breeches, a rough work shirt, and heavy boots far too large for her. Peter recognizes the clothes and understands where she obtained them. The detail links her flight to her brother’s belongings, although the evidence does not establish how she acquired them or what Peter knew of her journey at the time. His surprise at the disguise is brief; he does not turn the revelation into a reproach.
When Dominic worries that Rupert may suspect Isobel is there, Peter’s position within the household is clear: her return has not ended the danger. Dominic believes she is safest beside him, especially at night, but also recognizes that her recovery is bringing a wish to move about rather than remain in bed. Peter’s actions across these episodes—from seeking the Magistrate to finding his sister and accepting Dominic’s protection—place him among those trying to restore both her safety and her place within the family. The movement from a grave at Leicestershire to Isobel’s sickroom reverses the loss he had mourned, while leaving Rupert’s threat unresolved.


